- html - 出于某种原因,IE8 对我的 Sass 文件中继承的 html5 CSS 不友好?
- JMeter 在响应断言中使用 span 标签的问题
- html - 在 :hover and :active? 上具有不同效果的 CSS 动画
- html - 相对于居中的 html 内容固定的 CSS 重复背景?
好的,因此您可以阅读有关标识符命名的准则,“直到您脸色发青…… Camel 案,帕斯卡案,使它们具有描述性……”但它们实际上并不能帮助您为给定名称选择最佳名称应用程序域。
最容易选择的(IMHO)是一个或两个单词名词组:
最佳答案
我一直在阅读罗伯特·C·马丁(Robert C. Martin)的“干净代码”,还没有从第17章开始读到本节,但是我认为它离回答这个问题最近。
N1: Choose Descriptive Names
Don’t be too quick to choose a name. Make sure the name is descriptive. Remember that meanings tend to drift as software evolves, so frequently reevaluate the appropriateness of the names you choose. This is not just a “feel-good” recommendation. Names in software are 90 percent of what make software readable. You need to take the time to choose them wisely and keep them relevant. Names are too important to treat carelessly. Consider the code below. What does it do? If I show you the code with well-chosen names, it will make perfect sense to you, but like this it’s just a hodge-podge of symbols and magic numbers.
public int x() {
int q = 0;
int z = 0;
for (int kk = 0; kk < 10; kk++) {
if (l[z] == 10)
{
q += 10 + (l[z + 1] + l[z + 2]);
z += 1;
}
else if (l[z] + l[z + 1] == 10)
{
q += 10 + l[z + 2];
z += 2;
} else {
q += l[z] + l[z + 1];
z += 2;
}
}
return q;
}Here is the code the way it should be written. This snippet is actually less complete than the one above. Yet you can infer immediately what it is trying to do, and you could very likely write the missing functions based on that inferred meaning. The magic numbers are no longer magic, and the structure of the algorithm is compellingly descriptive.
public int score() {
int score = 0;
int frame = 0;
for (int frameNumber = 0; frameNumber < 10; frameNumber++) {
if (isStrike(frame)) {
score += 10 + nextTwoBallsForStrike(frame);
frame += 1;
} else if (isSpare(frame)) {
score += 10 + nextBallForSpare(frame);
frame += 2;
} else {
score += twoBallsInFrame(frame);
frame += 2;
}
}
return score;
}The power of carefully chosen names is that they overload the structure of the code with description. That overloading sets the readers’ expectations about what the other functions in the module do. You can infer the implementation of isStrike() by looking at the code above. When you read the isStrike method, it will be “pretty much what you expected.”
private boolean isStrike(int frame) {
return rolls[frame] == 10;
}N2: Choose Names at the Appropriate Level of Abstraction
Don’t pick names that communicate implementation; choose names the reflect the level of abstraction of the class or function you are working in. This is hard to do. Again, people are just too good at mixing levels of abstractions. Each time you make a pass over your code, you will likely find some variable that is named at too low a level. You should take the opportunity to change those names when you find them. Making code readable requires a dedication to continuous improvement. Consider the Modem interface below:
public interface Modem {
boolean dial(String phoneNumber);
boolean disconnect();
boolean send(char c);
char recv();
String getConnectedPhoneNumber();
}At first this looks fine. The functions all seem appropriate. Indeed, for many applications they are. But now consider an application in which some modems aren’t connected by dialing. Rather they are connected permanently by hard wiring them together (think of the cable modems that provide Internet access to most homes nowadays). Perhaps some are connected by sending a port number to a switch over a USB connection. Clearly the notion of phone numbers is at the wrong level of abstraction. A better naming strategy for this scenario might be:
public interface Modem {
boolean connect(String connectionLocator);
boolean disconnect();
boolean send(char c);
char recv();
String getConnectedLocator();
}Now the names don’t make any commitments about phone numbers. They can still be used for phone numbers, or they could be used for any other kind of connection strategy.
N3: Use Standard Nomenclature Where Possible
Names are easier to understand if they are based on existing convention or usage. For example, if you are using the DECORATOR pattern, you should use the word Decorator in the names of the decorating classes. For example, AutoHangupModemDecorator might be the name of a class that decorates a Modem with the ability to automatically hang up at the end of a session. Patterns are just one kind of standard. In Java, for example, functions that convert objects to string representations are often named toString. It is better to follow conventions like these than to invent your own. Teams will often invent their own standard system of names for a particular project. Eric Evans refers to this as a ubiquitous language for the project. Your code should use the terms from this language extensively. In short, the more you can use names that are overloaded with special meanings that are relevant to your project, the easier it will be for readers to know what your code is talking about.
N4: Unambiguous Names
Choose names that make the workings of a function or variable unambiguous. Consider this example from FitNesse:
private String doRename() throws Exception
{
if(refactorReferences)
renameReferences();
renamePage();
pathToRename.removeNameFromEnd();
pathToRename.addNameToEnd(newName);
return PathParser.render(pathToRename);
}The name of this function does not say what the function does except in broad and vague terms. This is emphasized by the fact that there is a function named renamePage inside the function named doRename! What do the names tell you about the difference between the two functions? Nothing. A better name for that function is renamePageAndOptionallyAllReferences. This may seem long, and it is, but it’s only called from one place in the module, so it’s explanatory value outweighs the length.
N5: Use Long Names for Long Scopes
The length of a name should be related to the length of the scope. You can use very short variable names for tiny scopes, but for big scopes you should use longer names. Variable names like i and j are just fine if their scope is five lines long. Consider this snippet from the old standard “Bowling Game”:
private void rollMany(int n, int pins)
{
for (int i=0; i<n; i++)
g.roll(pins);
}This is perfectly clear and would be obfuscated if the variable i were replaced with something annoying like rollCount. On the other hand, variables and functions with short names lose their meaning over long distances. So the longer the scope of the name, the longer and more precise the name should be.
N6: Avoid Encodings
Names should not be encoded with type or scope information. Prefixes such as m_ or f are useless in today’s environments. Also project and/or subsystem encodings such as vis_ (for visual imaging system) are distracting and redundant. Again, today’s environments provide all that information without having to mangle the names. Keep your names free of Hungarian pollution.
N7: Names Should Describe Side-Effects
Names should describe everything that a function, variable, or class is or does. Don’t hide side effects with a name. Don’t use a simple verb to describe a function that does more than just that simple action. For example, consider this code from TestNG:
public ObjectOutputStream getOos() throws IOException {
if (m_oos == null) {
m_oos = new ObjectOutputStream(m_socket.getOutputStream());
}
return m_oos;
}This function does a bit more than get an “oos”; it creates the “oos” if it hasn’t been created already. Thus, a better name might be createOrReturnOos.
关于naming-conventions - 选择好的标识符名称,我们在Stack Overflow上找到一个类似的问题: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/841888/
我有一堆字符串,其中包含以姓氏,名字格式命名的名称列表,并用逗号分隔,如下所示: names 序列化字符串中的“first name last name”,我们在Stack Overflow上找到一个
在尝试合并多个数据框时,我得到了一些非常奇怪的东西。帮助! 我需要通过“RID”和“VISCODE”列合并一堆数据框。这是它的外观示例: d1 = data.frame(ID = sample(9,
让我们尽可能简单地做第一个例子。 我想知道如何应用这个宏;像这里适用于例如printf("%s",macro(arg)); #include #include #include #define
以下2个bean声明之间有什么区别吗? @Bean(name = "bean1") public A getA() { return new A(); } @Bean @Quali
if(c.get_name(&name) && name && !strcmp(name, contName)) 谁能告诉我这行代码在 C++ 中的含义 最佳答案 如果 c 有一个名字并且它等于 co
我是 Rails 的初学者,在改进我的搜索查询时遇到了一些问题: 在我调用的 Controller 中: def index if params[:search] @persons = Pers
谁能帮我解决这段代码的最后一部分的编译错误它的说法创建构造函数请帮助 public class Officer { public static void main(String args[]
关闭。这个问题需要details or clarity .它目前不接受答案。 想改进这个问题吗? 通过 editing this post 添加细节并澄清问题. 关闭 8 年前。 Improve t
我创建了一个 Web 应用程序,它具有使用 JSF 技术的 createBook.xhtml 并且它使用托管 Bean。在此页面中,用户必须在输入字段中填写所需信息,然后点击提交按钮。然后应使用 do
嘿,我正在尝试弄清楚如何将在 mySQL 中工作的语句转换为 PostgreSQL 并且很好奇是否有人知道解决方案。 这是在 mySQL 中有效的语句: def self.by_name(keywor
如果我要创建所有类型的类型,而不是使用字符串和原始类型,那么最大的缺点是什么? 通常它看起来像: String name = person.getName(); int age = person.ge
我正在尝试从以下内容中提取郊区名称: 12 street name, suburb name, CTG 1234 在 PHP 中使用正则表达式。 街道和郊区名称都可以是任意数量的单词长度。 CTG 是
我有一个呈现个人详细信息组件的父组件,并且正在注入(inject)父组件的验证器范围。如果我使用 v-validate 指令和 this.$validator.validateAll() 或 this
现在,据我了解,name[] 声明中的 extern 告诉编译器它的定义在其他地方(在我的程序中,我定义了它低于我使用它的部分)。但是为什么 strlen() 和 sizeof 会有不同的结果?str
我一直在解决一个问题: "Design a program that asks the user for a series of names (in no particular order). Aft
我的 XML 如下所示: 我想使用 JAXB 来阅读该内容。 我知道我能做到 @XmlRootElement(name="thing") public class Thing{
对于字符串 name[],我们可以使用 strlen(name)+1 和 sizeof(name) 互换 在我们的代码中没有经过深思熟虑?他们不一样吗?我检查了一下,发现两者的返回类型都是相同的,si
我正在尝试从以下内容中提取郊区名称: 12 street name, suburb name, CTG 1234 在 PHP 中使用正则表达式。 街道和郊区名称的长度可以是任意数量。 CTG 是 st
关闭。这个问题需要details or clarity .它目前不接受答案。 想改进这个问题吗? 通过 editing this post 添加细节并澄清问题. 关闭 8 年前。 Improve t
bash 手册列出了 for 的语法。复合语句为for name [ [ in [ word ... ] ] ; ] do list ; done这意味着 do 之前的分号如果 in 是可选的子句省略
我是一名优秀的程序员,十分优秀!