delphi - 如何使用类助手调用受​​保护的方法？

Question

假设我们有一个类，其方法可能非常有用，但由于 protected 范围而不可用:

unit Sealed;

interface

type
  TGeneral = class(TObject)
    { this method is useful, but not available }
    protected procedure Useful; virtual;
  end;

  TSpecific1 = class(TGeneral)
    { some descendants override `Useful` method }
    protected procedure Useful; override;
  end;

  TSpecific2 = class(TGeneral)
    { and some dont, but inherit `Useful`ness from the parent }
  end;

我知道两种老式的方法来实现这种方法，都涉及继承和类型转换。这两种方法对于基本情况 #1 和高级多态情况 #2 的工作原理应该相同。

program CallingSite;

uses Sealed;

function GetInstance: TGeneral;
begin
  { !PSEUDO! makes compiler happy about the rest of code }
  // depending on use case supposed to return an instance of `TGeneral`
  // or any of its descendants - `TSpecific1`, `TSpecific2`
end;

type
  { this makes a current module a "friend" for `TGeneral` }
  TFriend = class(TGeneral)
  end;

procedure Case1;
var
  { holds an instance of `TGeneral` }
  General: TGeneral;
begin
  General := GetInstance;
  { protected method is available for "friend" via static cast }
  TFriend(General).Useful;  // compiles!
end;

type
  TIntroducer = class(TGeneral)
  { this "reintroduces" `Useful` method to public scope }
  public procedure Useful; override;
  // this approach ought to work even with strict protected methods
  // !!! but I THINK it is UNSAFE to use on virtual and/or dynamic methods
  end;

procedure TIntroducer.Useful;
begin
  { and calls `Useful` via wrapper }
  inherited;
end;

procedure Case2;
var
  { polymorphic instance of any `TGeneral`'s descendant }
  Specific: TGeneral;
begin
  Specific := GetInstance;
  { protected method is callable via public wrapper, static cast again }
  TIntroducer(Specific).Useful; // compiles!
end;

我想知道:

• 如何利用类助手的力量获得相同的结果？
• 是否也可以使用类助手调用私有(private)方法？
• 由于类帮助器增强了类作用域而不是内部表示，因此情况 #1 和情况 #2 之间会有任何差异吗？
• 如何从类助手中重新引入的方法调用原始方法而不冒递归风险？

另外，请评论有关 TIntroducer 不安全的评论。

Answer 1

您可以这样使用助手:

unit Unit2;

interface

type
  TGeneral = class(TObject)
    protected procedure Useful; virtual;
  end;

  TSpecific2 = class(TGeneral)
  end;

  TSpecificHelper = class helper for TGeneral
  public
    procedure ExposedUseful;
  end;

implementation

procedure TGeneral.Useful;
begin
  WriteLn('general');
end;

procedure TSpecificHelper.ExposedUseful;
begin
  Useful;
end;    

end.

这些甚至可以在单独的单元中声明，例如:

unit Unit2;

interface

type
  TGeneral = class(TObject)
    protected procedure Useful; virtual;
  end;

implementation

procedure TGeneral.Useful;
begin
  WriteLn('general');
end;

end.

分别

unit Unit3;

interface
uses
  Unit2;
type
  TSpecific2 = class(TGeneral)
  end;

  TSpecificHelper = class helper for TGeneral
  public
    procedure ExposedUseful;
  end;

implementation

procedure TSpecificHelper.ExposedUseful;
begin
  Useful;
end;

end.

并测试:

program Project1;


{$APPTYPE CONSOLE}

uses
  //Unit2,  // either or
  Unit3;

var
  foo : TSpecific2;
begin
  foo := TSpecific2.Create;
  foo.ExposedUseful;
  Readln;
end.

如果您为基类创建助手，则可以以类似的方式公开私有(private)成员。如果在不同的单位，则需要 Actor 。例如:

// in Unit2
TGeneral = class(TObject)
    private
      procedure AlsoUseful;
    protected
      procedure Useful; virtual;
  end;

//in Unit3

  TSpecificHelper = class helper for TGeneral
  public
    procedure ExposedUseful;
    procedure ExposedAlsoUseful;
  end;

// ...
implementation

procedure TSpecificHelper.ExposedAlsoUseful;
begin
  TGeneral(self).AlsoUseful;
end;

至于多态性，你真的可以自己测试一下。该帮助器将应用于您的实例派生自的任何后代类:

  TSpecific1 = class(TGeneral)
    protected
      procedure Useful; override;
  end;

// ...

procedure TSpecific1.Useful;
begin
  WriteLn('specific 1');
end;

哪里

TSpecific2 = class(TSpecific1)
end;

使用上述基类的帮助程序调用时，将生成输出特定 1。

注意
从 Delphi 10.1 Berlin 开始，类助手无法再访问严格 protected 、严格私有(private)或私有(private)成员。这个“功能”实际上是一个编译器错误，Embarcadero 现已在柏林修复。
通过助手访问普通 protected 成员仍然是可能的。