- html - 出于某种原因,IE8 对我的 Sass 文件中继承的 html5 CSS 不友好?
- JMeter 在响应断言中使用 span 标签的问题
- html - 在 :hover and :active? 上具有不同效果的 CSS 动画
- html - 相对于居中的 html 内容固定的 CSS 重复背景?
底部的程序应该返回目标缺失的子句,在这种情况下 p(1, 3, fire)
是可证明的。
问题是它返回一个“太多”的解决方案,如输出中的最后一个解决方案所示:
?- main.
MISSING PREMISES:
p(A,2,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)
p(B,2,johnDroppedAMatch)
true ;
MISSING PREMISES:
p(A,2,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)
p(B,1,johnWasTired)
true ;
MISSING PREMISES:
precedes(3,3)
p(A,3,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)
p(B,2,johnWasTired)
true ;
false.
我想要的只是:
MISSING PREMISES:
p(A,2,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)
p(B,2,johnDroppedAMatch)
true ;
MISSING PREMISES:
p(A,2,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)
p(B,1,johnWasTired)
true ;
我很难理解哪里出了问题,希望能得到一些改进的提示 :-),或者一些文献提示(我已经熟悉 Markus Triska 的优秀页面)。
重要的谓词是missing0(G, M)
,其中G
是目标,M
是缺失子句的列表。我对这个问题的怀疑之一是可能有无数个失败的子句,所以我错过了某种“停止”条件。
我发布了相同的 question在 SWI Prolog 论坛上,但没有得到任何回应。我正在运行 SWI Prolog。
% https://www.swi-prolog.org/pldoc/doc/_SWI_/library/clp/clpr.pl
:-use_module(library(clpr)).
% time is ordered
precedes(1, 2).
precedes(2, 3).
% knowledge
p(X1, T2, johnDroppedAMatch):-
p(X2, T1, johnWasTired),
precedes(T1, T2),
{X1 = 0.5 * X2}.
p(X1, T2, fire):-
p(X2, T1, presenceOfFlammableMaterial),
p(X3, T1, johnDroppedAMatch),
precedes(T1, T2),
{X1 = 0.7 * X2 * X3}.
% --- Reasoning about knowledge
missing(G, M) :- call(G),
M = ['There are no missing premises.'].
missing(G, M) :- \+clause(G, _),
M = ['There are no clauses for the goal.'].
missing(G, M) :- clause(G, B), \+G, missing0(B, M).
% -- Look for missing clauses in a conjunction
missing0(G, M) :- G = (G1, G2), !,
missing0(G1, M1), missing0(G2, M2), append(M1, M2, M).
% -- Look for missing clauses in a disjunction
missing0(G, M) :- G = (G1; _), missing0(G1, M).
% -- Look for missing clauses in a disjunction
missing0(G, M) :- G = (_; G2), missing0(G2, M).
% -- If G is callable then it is not missing
missing0(G, M) :- call(G), M = [].
% G fails, and is neither a conjunction nor a disjunction, so
% put in in M. Here I collect missing clauses.
missing0(G, M) :- \+G, G \= (_, _), G \= (_; _), M = [G].
% If G fails and if B is in the body of G, check what predicates are
% missing for B to be provable. G \= {_} is to avoid an error when
% using clause/2 on clpr predicates.
missing0(G, M) :- \+G, G \= {_}, clause(G, B), missing0(B, M).
showMissing(M) :- copy_term_nat(M, M1),
numbervars(M1, 0, _, [attvar(bind)]),
sort(M1, M2),
nl, writeln('MISSING PREMISES:'),
maplist(writeln, M2).
main :- missing(p(1, 3, fire), M), showMissing(M).
最佳答案
不是答案,但我对代码进行了一些尝试,添加了一些打印输出并使其具有确定性。它现在报告一个解决方案。
这是原始代码,带有一些打印输出。它的报告与以前完全一样,输出没有排序,以便能够跟踪它首先命中的内容。
:-use_module(library(clpr)).
% ======================
% knowledge
% ======================
% time is ordered
% Note: Time is not transitive as precedes(1,3) is missing!
precedes(1, 2).
precedes(2, 3).
p(X1, T2, johnDroppedAMatch):-
p(X2, T1, johnWasTired),
precedes(T1, T2),
{X1 = 0.5 * X2}.
p(X1, T2, fire):-
p(X2, T1, presenceOfFlammableMaterial),
p(X3, T1, johnDroppedAMatch),
precedes(T1, T2),
{X1 = 0.7 * X2 * X3}.
% ======================
% reasoning about knowledge
% ======================
% Note: What exactly does it mean for a premise to be "missing"?
% Are variables to be resolved when reporting?
missing(G, M) :- call(G),
M = ['There are no missing premises.'].
missing(G, M) :- \+clause(G, _),
M = ['There are no clauses for the goal.'].
missing(G, M) :- clause(G, B), \+G, missingr(B, M, 0).
% --- Recursively look for missing stuff in a goal
% D is the Depth of the analysis
% SP is a string of spaces for indentation
missingr(G, M, D) :- G = (G1, G2), !,
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» AND «~w»\n",[SP,G1,G2]), spinc(D,DP),
missingr(G1, M1, DP),
missingr(G2, M2, DP),
append(M1, M2, M).
missingr(G, M, D) :- G = (G1; _), !,
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» OR «~w»\n",[SP,G1,"..."]), spinc(D,DP),
missingr(G1, M, DP).
missingr(G, M, D) :- G = (_ ; G2), !,
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» OR «~w»\n",[SP,"...",G2]), spinc(D,DP),
missingr(G2, M, DP).
missingr(G, M, D) :- sp(D,SP), format("~wMaybe «~w» can be called?\n",[SP,G]),
call(G),
format("~w«~w» succeeds; nothing is missing here.\n",[SP,G]),
M = [].
missingr(G, M, D) :- \+G, G \= (_,_), G \= (_;_),
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» is not provable, not a conjunction, not a disjunction: Consider missing!\n",[SP,G]),
M = [G].
missingr(G, M, D) :- \+G, G \= {_}, clause(G, B),
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» is not provable, not a constraint, and a clause with body «~w», continue with body\n",[SP,G,B]), spinc(D,DP),
missingr(B, M, DP).
% Igniter
showMissing(M) :- copy_term_nat(M, M1),
numbervars(M1, 0, _, [attvar(bind)]),
% sort(M1, M2), % do not sort so that terms are output in found order
M2 = M1,
nl, writeln('MISSING PREMISES:'),
maplist(writeln, M2).
main :- missing(p(1, 3, fire), M), showMissing(M).
% Generate string of N spaces fast.
spinc(In,Out) :- Out is In+2.
sp(0,"") :- !.
sp(1,".") :- !.
sp(Len,Str) :- Len > 1,
Lenx is Len div 2, Remx is Len rem 2,
sp(Lenx,Strx),
string_concat(Strx,Strx,Stry),
(Remx == 0 -> Str = Stry ; string_concat(Stry,".",Str)),!.
?- main.
«p(_7002,_7004,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)» AND «p(_7010,_7004,johnDroppedAMatch),precedes(_7004,3),{1=0.7*_7002*_7010}»
..Maybe «p(_7002,_7004,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)» can be called?
..«p(_7002,_7004,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)» is not provable, not a conjunction, not a disjunction: Consider missing!
..«p(_7010,_7004,johnDroppedAMatch)» AND «precedes(_7004,3),{1=0.7*_7002*_7010}»
....Maybe «p(_7010,_7004,johnDroppedAMatch)» can be called?
....«p(_7010,_7004,johnDroppedAMatch)» is not provable, not a conjunction, not a disjunction: Consider missing!
....«precedes(_7004,3)» AND «{1=0.7*_7002*_7010}»
......Maybe «precedes(_7004,3)» can be called?
......«precedes(2,3)» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
......Maybe «{1=0.7*_7002*_7010}» can be called?
......«{1=0.7*_7914*_7940}» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
MISSING PREMISES:
p(A,2,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)
p(B,2,johnDroppedAMatch)
true ;
....«p(_7010,_7004,johnDroppedAMatch)» is not provable, not a constraint, and a clause with body «p(_7278,_7280,johnWasTired),precedes(_7280,_7004),{_7010=0.5*_7278}», continue with body
......«p(_7278,_7280,johnWasTired)» AND «precedes(_7280,_7004),{_7010=0.5*_7278}»
........Maybe «p(_7278,_7280,johnWasTired)» can be called?
........«p(_7278,_7280,johnWasTired)» is not provable, not a conjunction, not a disjunction: Consider missing!
........«precedes(_7280,_7004)» AND «{_7010=0.5*_7278}»
..........Maybe «precedes(_7280,_7004)» can be called?
..........«precedes(1,2)» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
..........Maybe «{_7010=0.5*_7278}» can be called?
..........«{_8266=0.5*_8368}» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
....«precedes(2,3)» AND «{1=0.7*_7002*_8266}»
......Maybe «precedes(2,3)» can be called?
......«precedes(2,3)» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
......Maybe «{1=0.7*_7002*_8266}» can be called?
......«{1=0.7*_9472*_8266}» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
MISSING PREMISES:
p(A,2,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)
p(B,1,johnWasTired)
true ;
..........«precedes(2,3)» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
..........Maybe «{_7010=0.5*_7278}» can be called?
..........«{_8266=0.5*_8368}» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
....«precedes(3,3)» AND «{1=0.7*_7002*_8266}»
......Maybe «precedes(3,3)» can be called?
......«precedes(3,3)» is not provable, not a conjunction, not a disjunction: Consider missing!
......Maybe «{1=0.7*_7002*_8266}» can be called?
......«{1=0.7*_9476*_8266}» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
MISSING PREMISES:
p(A,3,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)
p(B,2,johnWasTired)
precedes(3,3)
true ;
false.
考虑到这一点,就不清楚“缺少谓词” 是什么意思,甚至不清楚在解释过程中遇到合取或析取时应该发生什么。需要更多细节!
这里是修改后的代码,它似乎符合要求,但更具确定性,只输出一个解决方案:
:-use_module(library(clpr)).
% ======================
% knowledge
% ======================
% time is ordered
% Note: Time is not transitive as precedes(1,3) is missing!
precedes(1, 2).
precedes(2, 3).
p(X1, T2, johnDroppedAMatch):-
p(X2, T1, johnWasTired),
precedes(T1, T2),
{X1 = 0.5 * X2}.
p(X1, T2, fire):-
p(X2, T1, presenceOfFlammableMaterial),
p(X3, T1, johnDroppedAMatch),
precedes(T1, T2),
{X1 = 0.7 * X2 * X3}.
% ======================
% reasoning about knowledge
% ======================
% Note: What exactly does it mean for a premise to be "missing"?
% Are variables to be resolved when reporting?
missing(G, M) :- call(G),
M = ['There are no missing premises.'].
missing(G, M) :- \+clause(G, _),
M = ['There are no clauses for the goal.'].
missing(G, M) :- clause(G, B), \+G, missingr(B, M, 0).
% --- Recursively look for missing stuff in a goal
% Conjunction
% In a conjunction we can fail on left or right, go down both branches.
missingr(G, M, D) :- G = (G1, G2), !,
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» AND «~w»\n",[SP,G1,G2]), spinc(D,DP),
missingr(G1, M1, DP),
missingr(G2, M2, DP),
append(M1, M2, M).
% Disjunction. Finagle a proper guard!
% Note: In a disjunction we fail if we fail on both sides, but then what to report???
missingr(G, M, D) :- G = (G1; G2), !,
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» OR «~w»\n",[SP,G1,G2]), spinc(D,DP),
(missingr(G1, M, DP) ; missingr(G2, M, DP)).
% If G is callable and succeeds then it is not missing.
% The call will unify variables, which may or may not be what we want.
missingr(G, M, D) :- sp(D,SP), format("~wMaybe «~w» can be called?\n",[SP,G]),
call(G), !,
format("~w«~w» succeeds; nothing is missing here.\n",[SP,G]),
M = [].
% If G fails and if B is the body of G, check what predicates are
% missing for B to be provable. G \= {_} is to avoid an error when
% using clause/2 on clpr predicates.
missingr(G, M, D) :- \+G, !,
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» is nonprovable\n",[SP,G]), spinc(D,DP),
nonprovable(G, M, DP).
nonprovable(G, M, D) :- G \= {_}, clause(G, B), !,
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» is a nonprovable clause with body «~w», continue with body\n",[SP,G,B]), spinc(D,DP),
missingr(B, M, DP).
nonprovable(G, M, D) :- G \= {_}, !,
sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» is a nonprovable non-clause: considered missing!\n",[SP,G]),
M = [G].
nonprovable(G, M, D) :- sp(D,SP), format("~w«~w» is a constraint; dropped!\n",[SP,G]),
M = [].
% Igniter
showMissing(M) :- copy_term_nat(M, M1),
numbervars(M1, 0, _, [attvar(bind)]),
nl, writeln('MISSING PREMISES:'),
maplist(writeln, M1).
main :- missing(p(1, 3, fire), M), showMissing(M).
% Generate string of N spaces fast.
spinc(In,Out) :- Out is In+2.
sp(0,"") :- !.
sp(1,".") :- !.
sp(Len,Str) :- Len > 1,
Lenx is Len div 2, Remx is Len rem 2,
sp(Lenx,Strx),
string_concat(Strx,Strx,Stry),
(Remx == 0 -> Str = Stry ; string_concat(Stry,".",Str)),!.
运行它会生成一个解决方案:
?- main.
«p(_5182,_5184,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)» AND «p(_5190,_5184,johnDroppedAMatch),precedes(_5184,3),{1=0.7*_5182*_5190}»
..Maybe «p(_5182,_5184,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)» can be called?
..«p(_5182,_5184,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)» is nonprovable
....«p(_5182,_5184,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)» is a nonprovable non-clause: considered missing!
..«p(_5190,_5184,johnDroppedAMatch)» AND «precedes(_5184,3),{1=0.7*_5182*_5190}»
....Maybe «p(_5190,_5184,johnDroppedAMatch)» can be called?
....«p(_5190,_5184,johnDroppedAMatch)» is nonprovable
......«p(_5190,_5184,johnDroppedAMatch)» is a nonprovable clause with body «p(_5572,_5574,johnWasTired),precedes(_5574,_5184),{_5190=0.5*_5572}»,
........«p(_5572,_5574,johnWasTired)» AND «precedes(_5574,_5184),{_5190=0.5*_5572}»
..........Maybe «p(_5572,_5574,johnWasTired)» can be called?
..........«p(_5572,_5574,johnWasTired)» is nonprovable
............«p(_5572,_5574,johnWasTired)» is a nonprovable non-clause: considered missing!
..........«precedes(_5574,_5184)» AND «{_5190=0.5*_5572}»
............Maybe «precedes(_5574,_5184)» can be called?
............«precedes(1,2)» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
............Maybe «{_5190=0.5*_5572}» can be called?
............«{_6626=0.5*_6728}» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
....«precedes(2,3)» AND «{1=0.7*_5182*_6626}»
......Maybe «precedes(2,3)» can be called?
......«precedes(2,3)» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
......Maybe «{1=0.7*_5182*_6626}» can be called?
......«{1=0.7*_7658*_6626}» succeeds; nothing is missing here.
MISSING PREMISES:
p(A,2,presenceOfFlammableMaterial)
p(B,1,johnWasTired)
true.
但如前所述,我们真正想要的是什么?
关于prolog - 用于查找可证明目标缺少哪些谓词的程序,我们在Stack Overflow上找到一个类似的问题: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/59520621/
我在 GlassFish (J2EE_1.4) 上的 NetBeans 中开发企业项目。我的项目中有一些实体 bean、一些 session bean 和消息驱动 bean。我以如下方式使用 serv
什么在速度方面更好...... 我正在尝试确定用户是否已将某个 URL 添加到他们的快捷方式列表中。如果他们添加了 URL,页面上就会有一个链接,用于从快捷方式中删除该页面,否则他们可以将其添加到快捷
我的问题如下: 我打开一个Excel-File,但我不知道我的客户在模板文件中使用了哪些可能的标头变量。它们可以是:#DATE,#TIME,#NAME等。因此,我需要查找这些变量,以及是否已使用过:替
我有一堆以“-e”结尾的文件要删除。 $ find . -name "*-e" exec rm {} \; find: exec: unknown primary or operator 正则表达式是
我有一个简单的问题:是否可以在 TypeScript 中获取联合的一部分的类型? 例如,您可以经常使用如下查找类型: interface Person { name: string; } type
我正在尝试设置 Point Cloud Library启用 CUDA 选项的主干构建。 我相信我已经按照 these instructions 正确安装了 CUDA . 在 PCL 构建的 cmake
我将首先说我所知道的唯一 VBA 是操作录制的宏的反复试验。我是一名注册会计师,试图以艰难的方式学习 VBA(并希望我去学校学习计算机编程!)。 我有带有多个工作表的大型工作簿。 G 列中以黄色突出显
当文件数达到阈值时,我试图删除目录中最旧的文件。 list_of_files = os.listdir('log') if len([name for name in list_of_files
我有一个数组,它有一些重复的值。 我必须计算每个重复项的数量及其索引。 打印如: Index of b: 1 Index of b: 4 Index of c: 2 Index of c: 3 Ind
我已经搜索了我的问题的解决方案,但没有成功。热键 ctrl+F 找到的 eclipse 查找/替换功能不起作用。注意:通过 Eclipse 菜单 Edit>Find Replace(不工作我的意思是
我想检查 div 是否包含类为“error”的子级,但条件是错误类显示不等于无。 (意味着错误类必须可见。 如何更改我的以下代码: $(".related_field").each(function
这个问题已经有答案了: 已关闭13 年前。 Possible Duplicate: Can jQuery provide the tag name? 嗨! 这个问题太基础了,我不好意思问,但我尝试了
我一直听说这是 cygwin 的路径问题。它阻止了 emacs 在我的 cygwin 中工作。当我在 cli(不是 bash/cygwin)上执行 find 时,无论我输入什么,我都会得到同样的错误。
我正在使用此变量来获取一个或多个与我需要的值相匹配的值。 var mail = $("#dat").contents().find("td:contains('" + name + "')" ).si
请原谅这个长问题。我只是不确定解决这个问题的最佳方法是什么。 我有一个电子表格(Google 表格),其中包含用户和地址列表,我需要从中创建邮寄标签。该电子表格是从我们的学生信息系统导出的。这些地址应
我正在 Excel VBA 中创建一个公式,以解析单元格中以逗号分隔的“部分”列表。在另一个工作表中查找具有该零件名称的单元格,然后使用找到的该单元格的地址来获取同一行不同列的零件成本。我为此工作了数
我被要求在网络应用程序上实现一些电子邮件地址验证 - 我确信我们都已经经历过一千次了...但是,这一次我被要求在域上进行 MX 查找查看它是否接受电子邮件。 有人知道这样做有任何潜在的问题吗? mx
我有一个切换按钮,可读取.wave文件,并且字符串更改为暂停,然后..... 我的问题是,当用户播放声音时,按钮字符串更改为暂停,结束声音后,该字符串仍为暂停状态,我想将其更改为播放。但是我不知道如何
对于令人困惑的标题提前表示歉意。我的问题如下,我在大约 600 个文件中有以下文本: $_REQUEST['FOO'] 我想将其替换为以下内容: $this->input->post('FOO') 为
我正在使用 Ansible 的查找功能查找 INI 文件中的值。这是文档中的示例: - debug: msg="User in integration is {{ lookup('ini', 'use
我是一名优秀的程序员,十分优秀!