- html - 出于某种原因,IE8 对我的 Sass 文件中继承的 html5 CSS 不友好?
- JMeter 在响应断言中使用 span 标签的问题
- html - 在 :hover and :active? 上具有不同效果的 CSS 动画
- html - 相对于居中的 html 内容固定的 CSS 重复背景?
我们什么时候应该使用单例模式以及为什么?
最佳答案
http://sites.google.com/site/steveyegge2/singleton-considered-stupid
Why is the Singleton so attractive? I'll be the first to admit: I liked it too. No, scratch that - I loved the Singleton. It felt like an old friend from the moment I laid eyes on it. It was simple and beautiful.
I'll tell you why: it's because the Singleton pattern is a throwback to non-OO programming. It's a lifeline for people who didn't understand a single word that the Gang of Four were trying to say. I don't know how it got in there in the first place -- some political OOPSLA pressure, no doubt -- but it doesn't belong in there. It's Evil...
Here's the "short" summary...
a) I haven't covered even a tenth of the issues. But I'll name a few of them.
b) One is memory management; a Singleton is basically just a memory leak, if nobody is going to be using it for a while. But you have no idea when to deallocate it, because nobody's going to call you and say "nobody's going to be using you for a while!"
Besides, you can't tell who has kept around references to your Singleton instance, since you were pretty blase about handing it out, weren't you? (Note: Java's weak references can help with this issue).
c) Speaking of memory leaks, what if your Singleton has a handle to some limited resource, like a database or file handle? I guess you get to keep that sucker open until your program ends. Thank God C++ programs never last longer than about 10 minutes before crashing, usually from running out of resources, or from trying to access a Singleton that someone freed.
d) Another issue is that the Singleton design is syntactically noisy; most languages don't support it (well, Ruby does, sadly, but that was probably before Matz knew any better), so you have to stick in boilerplate code not only in the Singleton, but in everyone who uses it.
e) Then there's the subclassing thing. It's almost impossible to subclass a Singleton, and if you manage it, then you shouldn't have been using a Singleton in the first place. You don't even want to go there. I've walked roads that I dare not recount. Just pretend you can't do it, and you'll save yourself amazing amounts of pain.
f) static methods are as flexible as granite. Every time you use one, you're casting part of your program in concrete. Just make sure you don't have your foot jammed in there as you're watching it harden. Someday you will be amazed that, by gosh, you really DO need another implementation of that dang PrintSpooler class, and it should have been an interface, a factory, and a set of implementation classes. D'oh!
Don't suppose that's all. There are many other problems. For instance, try adding multithreading in and see what happens. Well, I'll tell you what happens: half the time, you get a Doubleton or a Tripleton, unless you're a synchronization expert, and having a Tripleton is about as desirable as having three Balrogs show up at your tea party. And even if you're a synchronization expert and get the double-check idiom right, you've still got one Balrog to deal with, and they're no picnic.
But these problems all fade into insignificance compared to the Big One, which is that the Singleton "pattern" encourages you to forget everything you know about OO design, since OO is hard, and procedural is easy...
关于design-patterns - 单例模式,我们在Stack Overflow上找到一个类似的问题: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/3319434/
单向链表 单向链表比顺序结构的线性表最大的好处就是不用保证存放的位置,它只需要用指针去指向下一个元素就能搞定。 单链表图解 图画的比较粗糙,简单的讲解一下: 上面四个长方形,每个长方
使用TCP,我正在设计一些类似于next的程序。 客户端在许多线程中的接收正在等待一台服务器的发送消息。但是,这是有条件的。 recv正在等待特定的发送消息。 例如 客户 thread 1: recv
我正在编写正则表达式来验证电子邮件。唯一让我困惑的是: 顶级域名可以使用单个字符吗?(例如:lockevn.c) 背景:我知道顶级域名可以是 2 个字符到任意字符(.uk、.us 到 .canon、.
是否可以在单个定义中定义同一 Controller 的多个路由? 例如: 我想要一个单一的定义 /, /about, /privacy-policy 使用类似的东西 _home: pat
我正在使用 objective-c开发针对 11.4 iOS 的单 View 应用程序,以及 Xcode版本是 9.4.1。 创建后有Main.storyboard和LaunchScreen.stor
我一直在尝试在 shell 程序中实现管道结构,如果我执行简单的命令(例如“hello | rev”),它就可以工作 但是当我尝试执行“head -c 1000000/dev/urandom | wc
此表包含主机和接口(interface)列UNIQUE 组合* 编辑:这个表也有一个自动递增的唯一 ID,抱歉我应该在之前提到这个 ** | host.... | interface..... |
我想将具有固定补丁大小的“std filter”应用于单 channel 图像。 也就是说,我希望 out[i,j] 等于 img[i,j] 附近的像素值的标准值。 对于那些熟悉 Matlab 的人,
假设我想进行网络调用并使用 rx.Single,因为我希望只有一个值。 我如何应用replay().autoConnect() 这样的东西,这样当我从多个来源订阅时网络调用就不会发生多次?我应该使用
我将图像从 rgb 转换为 YUV。现在我想单独找到亮度 channel 的平均值。你能告诉我如何实现这一目标吗?此外,有没有办法确定图像由多少个 channel 组成? 最佳答案 你可以这样做: #
在比较Go和Scala的语句结束检测时,我发现Scala的规则更丰富,即: A line ending is treated as a semicolon unless one of the foll
在IEEE 1800-2005或更高版本中,&和&&二进制运算符有什么区别?它们相等吗? 我注意到,当a和b的类型为bit时,这些coverpoint定义的行为相同: cp: coverpoint a
我正在使用Flutter的provider软件包。我要实现的是为一个 View 或页面提供一个简单的提供程序。因此,我在小部件中尝试了以下操作: Widget build(BuildContext c
我正在尝试在 cython 中使用 openmp。我需要在 cython 中做两件事: i) 在我的 cython 代码中使用 #pragma omp single{} 作用域。 ii) 使用#pra
我正在尝试从转义字符字符串中删除单引号和双引号。它对单引号 ' 或双自动 " 不起作用。 请问有人可以帮忙吗? var mysting = escapedStr.replace(/^%22/g, '
我正在尝试在 cython 中使用 openmp。我需要在 cython 中做两件事: i) 在我的 cython 代码中使用 #pragma omp single{} 作用域。 ii) 使用#pra
我正在使用 ANT+ 协议(protocol),将智能手机与 ANT+ USB 加密狗连接,该加密狗通过 SimulANT+ 连接到 PC。 SimulANT+ 正在模拟一个心率传感器,它将数据发送到
有人可以解释/理解单/多线程模式下计算结果的不同吗? 这是一个大约的例子。圆周率的计算: #include #include #include const int itera(100000000
我编写了一个粗略的阴影映射实现,它使用 6 个不同的 View 矩阵渲染场景 6 次以创建立方体贴图。 作为优化,我正在尝试使用几何着色器升级到单 channel 方法,但很难从我的着色器获得任何输出
尝试使用 Single-Spa 构建一些东西并面临添加到应用程序 AngularJS 的问题。 Angular2 和 ReactJs 工作完美,但如果添加 AngularJS 并尝试为此应用程序使用
我是一名优秀的程序员,十分优秀!