r - 为什么在套索回归中计算 MSE 会给出不同的输出？

Question

我正在尝试对 lasso2 包中的前列腺癌数据运行不同的回归模型。当我使用 Lasso 时，我看到两种不同的方法来计算均方误差。但它们确实给了我完全不同的结果，所以我想知道我是否做错了什么，或者这是否仅仅意味着一种方法比另一种方法更好？

# Needs the following R packages.
library(lasso2)
library(glmnet)

# Gets the prostate cancer dataset
data(Prostate)

# Defines the Mean Square Error function 
mse = function(x,y) { mean((x-y)^2)}

# 75% of the sample size.
smp_size = floor(0.75 * nrow(Prostate))

# Sets the seed to make the partition reproductible.
set.seed(907)
train_ind = sample(seq_len(nrow(Prostate)), size = smp_size)

# Training set
train = Prostate[train_ind, ]

# Test set
test = Prostate[-train_ind, ]

# Creates matrices for independent and dependent variables.
xtrain = model.matrix(lpsa~. -1, data = train)
ytrain = train$lpsa
xtest = model.matrix(lpsa~. -1, data = test)
ytest = test$lpsa

# Fitting a linear model by Lasso regression on the "train" data set
pr.lasso = cv.glmnet(xtrain,ytrain,type.measure='mse',alpha=1)
lambda.lasso = pr.lasso$lambda.min

# Getting predictions on the "test" data set and calculating the mean     square error
lasso.pred = predict(pr.lasso, s = lambda.lasso, newx = xtest) 

# Calculating MSE via the mse function defined above
mse.1 = mse(lasso.pred,ytest)
cat("MSE (method 1): ", mse.1, "\n")

# Calculating MSE via the cvm attribute inside the pr.lasso object
mse.2 = pr.lasso$cvm[pr.lasso$lambda == lambda.lasso]
cat("MSE (method 2): ", mse.2, "\n")

所以这些是我为 MSE 得到的输出:

MSE (method 1): 0.4609978 
MSE (method 2): 0.5654089 

而且它们完全不同。有谁知道为什么？预先非常感谢您的帮助!

塞缪尔

Answer 1

正如 @alistaire 所指出的，在第一种情况下，您使用测试数据来计算 MSE，在第二种情况下，报告来自交叉验证(训练)折叠的 MSE，因此这不是一个同类的情况比较。

我们可以执行类似以下的操作来进行同类比较(通过在训练折叠上保留拟合值)，并且我们可以看到，如果在相同的训练折叠上计算，则 mse.1 和 mse.2 完全相等(尽管该值与您的值略有不同，但我的桌面 R 版本 3.1.2、x86_64-w64-mingw32、windows 10):

# Needs the following R packages.
library(lasso2)
library(glmnet)

# Gets the prostate cancer dataset
data(Prostate)

# Defines the Mean Square Error function 
mse = function(x,y) { mean((x-y)^2)}

# 75% of the sample size.
smp_size = floor(0.75 * nrow(Prostate))

# Sets the seed to make the partition reproductible.
set.seed(907)
train_ind = sample(seq_len(nrow(Prostate)), size = smp_size)

# Training set
train = Prostate[train_ind, ]

# Test set
test = Prostate[-train_ind, ]

# Creates matrices for independent and dependent variables.
xtrain = model.matrix(lpsa~. -1, data = train)
ytrain = train$lpsa
xtest = model.matrix(lpsa~. -1, data = test)
ytest = test$lpsa

# Fitting a linear model by Lasso regression on the "train" data set
# keep the fitted values on the training folds
pr.lasso = cv.glmnet(xtrain,ytrain,type.measure='mse', keep=TRUE, alpha=1)
lambda.lasso = pr.lasso$lambda.min
lambda.id <- which(pr.lasso$lambda == pr.lasso$lambda.min)

# get the predicted values on the training folds with lambda.min (not from test data)
mse.1 = mse(pr.lasso$fit[,lambda.id], ytrain) 
cat("MSE (method 1): ", mse.1, "\n")

MSE (method 1):  0.6044496 

# Calculating MSE via the cvm attribute inside the pr.lasso object
mse.2 = pr.lasso$cvm[pr.lasso$lambda == lambda.lasso]
cat("MSE (method 2): ", mse.2, "\n")

MSE (method 2):  0.6044496 

mse.1 == mse.2
[1] TRUE