google-app-engine - GCP 中的 AWS Elastic Beanstalk 相当于什么？

Question

AWS 的 Elastic Beanstalk 是 GCP 的 GAE 的答案吗？

两者之间是否有任何基准比较？

Answer 1

Is Elastic beanstalk of AWS an answer to GAE of GCP?

是的，简而言之，你可以这样想。

有一个 article Google 展示了 AWS 和 Google Cloud 产品的并排比较，将它们列为 IaaS 和 PaaS:

Service     AWS                             Google Cloud Platform
-----------------------------------------------------------------
IaaS        Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud    Compute Engine
PaaS        AWS Elastic Beanstalk           App Engine

但是，值得注意的是，至少 AWS Elastic Beanstalk 严格来说并不是一个 PaaS 解决方案，我更愿意将其描述为 EC2 之上的一个管理层。来自他们的 FAQ :

Q: How is AWS Elastic Beanstalk different from existing application containers or platform-as-a-service solutions?

Most existing application containers or platform-as-a-service solutions, while reducing the amount of programming required, significantly diminish developers’ flexibility and control. Developers are forced to live with all the decisions predetermined by the vendor–with little to no opportunity to take back control over various parts of their application’s infrastructure. However, with AWS Elastic Beanstalk, developers retain full control over the AWS resources powering their application. If developers decide they want to manage some (or all) of the elements of their infrastructure, they can do so seamlessly by using Elastic Beanstalk’s management capabilities.

我认为无法将这些平台与基准进行比较。您仍然可以在此平台上进行很多配置，性能将主要取决于您的配置和(甚至更多)您的应用程序代码。

这归结为这些平台上的定价、易用性和其他服务的可用性方面的差异。