java - 为什么这个算法的运行时间是 O(m+n)？

Question

我不明白下面算法的运行时间怎么可以是O(m+n)。关于算法，它用于找到两个列表的公共(public)节点(两个列表的长度可以不同)。

 if (len1 < len2)
  {
      head1 = list2;
      head2 = list1;
      diff = len2 - len1;
  }

这应该是 O(1)。

for(int i = 0; i < diff; i++)
      head1 = head1->next;

O(n)

while(head1 !=  NULL && head2 != NULL)
  {
      if(head1 == head2)
          return head1->data;
      head1= head1->next;
      head2= head2->next;
  }

O(n)

我总共达到了 O(n^2)...

这里是完整的算法:

struct node* findMergeNode(struct node* list1, struct node* list2)
{
  int len1, len2, diff;
  struct node* head1 = list1;
  struct node* head2 = list2;

  len1 = getlength(head1);
  len2 = getlength(head2);
  diff = len1 - len2;

  if (len1 < len2)
  {
      head1 = list2;
      head2 = list1;
      diff = len2 - len1;
  }

  for(int i = 0; i < diff; i++)
      head1 = head1->next;

  while(head1 !=  NULL && head2 != NULL)
  {
      if(head1 == head2)
          return head1->data;
      head1= head1->next;
      head2= head2->next;
  }

  return NULL;
}

Answer 1

您所做的只是相互独立地迭代给定的列表。实际上，这里花费时间最长的是确定列表的大小。 (如果 O(n+m))

struct node* findMergeNode(struct node* list1, struct node* list2)
{
    // Assuming list1 is of size m
    // Assuming list2 is of size n

    int len1, len2, diff;
    struct node* head1 = list1;
    struct node* head2 = list2;

    len1 = getlength(head1); // O(m) - as you need to iterate though it
    len2 = getlength(head2); // O(n) - same here
    diff = len1 - len2;

    // Right now you already reached O(m+n)

    if (len1 < len2) // O(1)
    {
        // this entire block is of constant length, as there are no loops or anything
        head1 = list2;
        head2 = list1;
        diff = len2 - len1;
    }

    // So we are still at O(m+n)

    for(int i = 0; i < diff; i++) // O(abs(m-n)) = O(diff)
        head1 = head1->next;

    // As diff = abs(m-n) which is smaller than m and n, we can 'ignore' this as well
    // So we are - again - still at O(m+n)

    while(head1 !=  NULL && head2 != NULL) // O(n-diff) or O(m-diff) - depending on the previous if-statement
    {
        // all the operations in here are of constant time as well
        // however, as we loop thorugh them, the time is as stated above
        if(head1 == head2)
            return head1->data;
        head1= head1->next;
        head2= head2->next;
    }

    // But here again: n-diff < n+m and m-diff < n+m
    // So we sill keep O(m+n)

    return NULL;
}

希望这对您有所帮助。