- iOS/Objective-C 元类和类别
- objective-c - -1001 错误,当 NSURLSession 通过 httpproxy 和/etc/hosts
- java - 使用网络类获取 url 地址
- ios - 推送通知中不播放声音
我是 Windows 中多线程的新手,所以这可能是一个微不足道的问题:确保线程同步执行循环的最简单方法是什么?
我尝试将 Event
的共享数组传递给所有线程,并在循环结束时使用 WaitForMultipleObjects
来同步它们,但这让我在一个线程后出现死锁,有时是两个,周期。这是我当前代码的简化版本(只有两个线程,但我想让它具有可扩展性):
typedef struct
{
int rank;
HANDLE* step_events;
} IterationParams;
int main(int argc, char **argv)
{
// ...
IterationParams p[2];
HANDLE step_events[2];
for (int j=0; j<2; ++j)
{
step_events[j] = CreateEvent(NULL, FALSE, FALSE, NULL);
}
for (int j=0; j<2; ++j)
{
p[j].rank = j;
p[j].step_events = step_events;
AfxBeginThread(Iteration, p+j);
}
// ...
}
UINT Iteration(LPVOID pParam)
{
IterationParams* p = (IterationParams*)pParam;
int rank = p->rank;
for (int i=0; i<100; i++)
{
if (rank == 0)
{
printf("%dth iteration\n",i);
// do something
SetEvent(p->step_events[0]);
WaitForMultipleObjects(2, p->step_events, TRUE, INFINITE);
}
else if (rank == 1)
{
// do something else
SetEvent(p->step_events[1]);
WaitForMultipleObjects(2, p->step_events, TRUE, INFINITE);
}
}
return 0;
}
(我知道我正在混合使用 C 和 C++,它实际上是我试图并行化的遗留 C 代码。)
阅读 MSDN 上的文档,我认为这应该可行。但是0号线程只打印一次,偶尔打印两次,然后程序就挂了。这是同步线程的正确方法吗?如果没有,您会推荐什么(MFC 中真的没有对屏障的内置支持吗?)。
编辑:这个解决方案错误,甚至包括Alessandro's fix .例如,考虑这种情况:
所以问题仍然存在:如何安全地确保线程保持同步?
最佳答案
我实现了一个简单的 C++ 程序供您考虑(在 Visual Studio 2010 中测试)。它仅使用 Win32 API(以及用于控制台输出和一些随机化的标准库)。您应该能够将它放入一个新的 Win32 控制台项目(没有预编译头文件),编译并运行。
#include <tchar.h>
#include <windows.h>
//---------------------------------------------------------
// Defines synchronization info structure. All threads will
// use the same instance of this struct to implement randezvous/
// barrier synchronization pattern.
struct SyncInfo
{
SyncInfo(int threadsCount) : Awaiting(threadsCount), ThreadsCount(threadsCount), Semaphore(::CreateSemaphore(0, 0, 1024, 0)) {};
~SyncInfo() { ::CloseHandle(this->Semaphore); }
volatile unsigned int Awaiting; // how many threads still have to complete their iteration
const int ThreadsCount;
const HANDLE Semaphore;
};
//---------------------------------------------------------
// Thread-specific parameters. Note that Sync is a reference
// (i.e. all threads share the same SyncInfo instance).
struct ThreadParams
{
ThreadParams(SyncInfo &sync, int ordinal, int delay) : Sync(sync), Ordinal(ordinal), Delay(delay) {};
SyncInfo &Sync;
const int Ordinal;
const int Delay;
};
//---------------------------------------------------------
// Called at the end of each itaration, it will "randezvous"
// (meet) all the threads before returning (so that next
// iteration can begin). In practical terms this function
// will block until all the other threads finish their iteration.
static void RandezvousOthers(SyncInfo &sync, int ordinal)
{
if (0 == ::InterlockedDecrement(&(sync.Awaiting))) { // are we the last ones to arrive?
// at this point, all the other threads are blocking on the semaphore
// so we can manipulate shared structures without having to worry
// about conflicts
sync.Awaiting = sync.ThreadsCount;
wprintf(L"Thread %d is the last to arrive, releasing synchronization barrier\n", ordinal);
wprintf(L"---~~~---\n");
// let's release the other threads from their slumber
// by using the semaphore
::ReleaseSemaphore(sync.Semaphore, sync.ThreadsCount - 1, 0); // "ThreadsCount - 1" because this last thread will not block on semaphore
}
else { // nope, there are other threads still working on the iteration so let's wait
wprintf(L"Thread %d is waiting on synchronization barrier\n", ordinal);
::WaitForSingleObject(sync.Semaphore, INFINITE); // note that return value should be validated at this point ;)
}
}
//---------------------------------------------------------
// Define worker thread lifetime. It starts with retrieving
// thread-specific parameters, then loops through 5 iterations
// (randezvous-ing with other threads at the end of each),
// and then finishes (the thread can then be joined).
static DWORD WINAPI ThreadProc(void *p)
{
ThreadParams *params = static_cast<ThreadParams *>(p);
wprintf(L"Starting thread %d\n", params->Ordinal);
for (int i = 1; i <= 5; ++i) {
wprintf(L"Thread %d is executing iteration #%d (%d delay)\n", params->Ordinal, i, params->Delay);
::Sleep(params->Delay);
wprintf(L"Thread %d is synchronizing end of iteration #%d\n", params->Ordinal, i);
RandezvousOthers(params->Sync, params->Ordinal);
}
wprintf(L"Finishing thread %d\n", params->Ordinal);
return 0;
}
//---------------------------------------------------------
// Program to illustrate iteration-lockstep C++ solution.
int _tmain(int argc, _TCHAR* argv[])
{
// prepare to run
::srand(::GetTickCount()); // pseudo-randomize random values :-)
SyncInfo sync(4);
ThreadParams p[] = {
ThreadParams(sync, 1, ::rand() * 900 / RAND_MAX + 100), // a delay between 200 and 1000 milliseconds will simulate work that an iteration would do
ThreadParams(sync, 2, ::rand() * 900 / RAND_MAX + 100),
ThreadParams(sync, 3, ::rand() * 900 / RAND_MAX + 100),
ThreadParams(sync, 4, ::rand() * 900 / RAND_MAX + 100),
};
// let the threads rip
HANDLE t[] = {
::CreateThread(0, 0, ThreadProc, p + 0, 0, 0),
::CreateThread(0, 0, ThreadProc, p + 1, 0, 0),
::CreateThread(0, 0, ThreadProc, p + 2, 0, 0),
::CreateThread(0, 0, ThreadProc, p + 3, 0, 0),
};
// wait for the threads to finish (join)
::WaitForMultipleObjects(4, t, true, INFINITE);
return 0;
}
在我的机器(双核)上运行这个程序会产生以下输出:
Starting thread 1
Starting thread 2
Starting thread 4
Thread 1 is executing iteration #1 (712 delay)
Starting thread 3
Thread 2 is executing iteration #1 (798 delay)
Thread 4 is executing iteration #1 (477 delay)
Thread 3 is executing iteration #1 (104 delay)
Thread 3 is synchronizing end of iteration #1
Thread 3 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 4 is synchronizing end of iteration #1
Thread 4 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 1 is synchronizing end of iteration #1
Thread 1 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 2 is synchronizing end of iteration #1
Thread 2 is the last to arrive, releasing synchronization barrier
---~~~---
Thread 2 is executing iteration #2 (798 delay)
Thread 3 is executing iteration #2 (104 delay)
Thread 1 is executing iteration #2 (712 delay)
Thread 4 is executing iteration #2 (477 delay)
Thread 3 is synchronizing end of iteration #2
Thread 3 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 4 is synchronizing end of iteration #2
Thread 4 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 1 is synchronizing end of iteration #2
Thread 1 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 2 is synchronizing end of iteration #2
Thread 2 is the last to arrive, releasing synchronization barrier
---~~~---
Thread 4 is executing iteration #3 (477 delay)
Thread 3 is executing iteration #3 (104 delay)
Thread 1 is executing iteration #3 (712 delay)
Thread 2 is executing iteration #3 (798 delay)
Thread 3 is synchronizing end of iteration #3
Thread 3 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 4 is synchronizing end of iteration #3
Thread 4 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 1 is synchronizing end of iteration #3
Thread 1 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 2 is synchronizing end of iteration #3
Thread 2 is the last to arrive, releasing synchronization barrier
---~~~---
Thread 2 is executing iteration #4 (798 delay)
Thread 3 is executing iteration #4 (104 delay)
Thread 1 is executing iteration #4 (712 delay)
Thread 4 is executing iteration #4 (477 delay)
Thread 3 is synchronizing end of iteration #4
Thread 3 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 4 is synchronizing end of iteration #4
Thread 4 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 1 is synchronizing end of iteration #4
Thread 1 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 2 is synchronizing end of iteration #4
Thread 2 is the last to arrive, releasing synchronization barrier
---~~~---
Thread 3 is executing iteration #5 (104 delay)
Thread 4 is executing iteration #5 (477 delay)
Thread 1 is executing iteration #5 (712 delay)
Thread 2 is executing iteration #5 (798 delay)
Thread 3 is synchronizing end of iteration #5
Thread 3 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 4 is synchronizing end of iteration #5
Thread 4 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 1 is synchronizing end of iteration #5
Thread 1 is waiting on synchronization barrier
Thread 2 is synchronizing end of iteration #5
Thread 2 is the last to arrive, releasing synchronization barrier
---~~~---
Finishing thread 4
Finishing thread 3
Finishing thread 2
Finishing thread 1
请注意,为简单起见,每个线程都有随机的迭代持续时间,但该线程的所有迭代都将使用相同的随机持续时间(即它在迭代之间不会改变)。
解决方案的“核心”在“RandezvousOthers”函数中。此函数将阻塞在共享信号量上(如果调用此函数的线程不是最后一个调用该函数的线程)或重置 Sync 结构并解除阻塞在共享信号量上的所有线程(如果此线程所在的线程)被调用的函数是最后一个调用该函数的函数)。
关于c++ - 如何使 Win32/MFC 线程同步循环?,我们在Stack Overflow上找到一个类似的问题: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4946025/
#include using namespace std; class C{ private: int value; public: C(){ value = 0;
这个问题已经有答案了: What is the difference between char a[] = ?string?; and char *p = ?string?;? (8 个回答) 已关闭
关闭。此题需要details or clarity 。目前不接受答案。 想要改进这个问题吗?通过 editing this post 添加详细信息并澄清问题. 已关闭 7 年前。 此帖子已于 8 个月
除了调试之外,是否有任何针对 c、c++ 或 c# 的测试工具,其工作原理类似于将独立函数复制粘贴到某个文本框,然后在其他文本框中输入参数? 最佳答案 也许您会考虑单元测试。我推荐你谷歌测试和谷歌模拟
我想在第二台显示器中移动一个窗口 (HWND)。问题是我尝试了很多方法,例如将分辨率加倍或输入负值,但它永远无法将窗口放在我的第二台显示器上。 关于如何在 C/C++/c# 中执行此操作的任何线索 最
我正在寻找 C/C++/C## 中不同类型 DES 的现有实现。我的运行平台是Windows XP/Vista/7。 我正在尝试编写一个 C# 程序,它将使用 DES 算法进行加密和解密。我需要一些实
很难说出这里要问什么。这个问题模棱两可、含糊不清、不完整、过于宽泛或夸夸其谈,无法以目前的形式得到合理的回答。如需帮助澄清此问题以便重新打开,visit the help center . 关闭 1
有没有办法强制将另一个 窗口置于顶部? 不是应用程序的窗口,而是另一个已经在系统上运行的窗口。 (Windows, C/C++/C#) 最佳答案 SetWindowPos(that_window_ha
假设您可以在 C/C++ 或 Csharp 之间做出选择,并且您打算在 Windows 和 Linux 服务器上运行同一服务器的多个实例,那么构建套接字服务器应用程序的最明智选择是什么? 最佳答案 如
你们能告诉我它们之间的区别吗? 顺便问一下,有什么叫C++库或C库的吗? 最佳答案 C++ 标准库 和 C 标准库 是 C++ 和 C 标准定义的库,提供给 C++ 和 C 程序使用。那是那些词的共同
下面的测试代码,我将输出信息放在注释中。我使用的是 gcc 4.8.5 和 Centos 7.2。 #include #include class C { public:
很难说出这里问的是什么。这个问题是含糊的、模糊的、不完整的、过于宽泛的或修辞性的,无法以目前的形式得到合理的回答。如需帮助澄清此问题以便重新打开它,visit the help center 。 已关
我的客户将使用名为 annoucement 的结构/类与客户通信。我想我会用 C++ 编写服务器。会有很多不同的类继承annoucement。我的问题是通过网络将这些类发送给客户端 我想也许我应该使用
我在 C# 中有以下函数: public Matrix ConcatDescriptors(IList> descriptors) { int cols = descriptors[0].Co
我有一个项目要编写一个函数来对某些数据执行某些操作。我可以用 C/C++ 编写代码,但我不想与雇主共享该函数的代码。相反,我只想让他有权在他自己的代码中调用该函数。是否可以?我想到了这两种方法 - 在
我使用的是编写糟糕的第 3 方 (C/C++) Api。我从托管代码(C++/CLI)中使用它。有时会出现“访问冲突错误”。这使整个应用程序崩溃。我知道我无法处理这些错误[如果指针访问非法内存位置等,
关闭。这个问题不符合Stack Overflow guidelines .它目前不接受答案。 我们不允许提问寻求书籍、工具、软件库等的推荐。您可以编辑问题,以便用事实和引用来回答。 关闭 7 年前。
已关闭。此问题不符合Stack Overflow guidelines 。目前不接受答案。 要求我们推荐或查找工具、库或最喜欢的场外资源的问题对于 Stack Overflow 来说是偏离主题的,因为
我有一些 C 代码,将使用 P/Invoke 从 C# 调用。我正在尝试为这个 C 函数定义一个 C# 等效项。 SomeData* DoSomething(); struct SomeData {
这个问题已经有答案了: Why are these constructs using pre and post-increment undefined behavior? (14 个回答) 已关闭 6
我是一名优秀的程序员,十分优秀!