c++ - 工业级n吨基类模板

Question

我正在研究一个 n-ton 基类模板。我还不担心懒惰，所以 Intent 是:

Ensure a class has only n instances, and provide a global point of access to them.

到目前为止，这是我的代码:

template<typename Derived, size_t n = 1>
class n_ton_base                 // Singletons are the default
{
    static Derived instances[n + (n == 0)];
                              // Zerotons are supported, too
protected:

    // Prevent n_ton_base to be used outside of inheritance hierarchies
    n_ton_base() {} 

    // Prevent n_ton_base (and Derived classes) from being copied
    n_ton_base(const n_ton_base&) = delete;

public:
                   // Get first element by default, useful for Singletons
    template<size_t i = 0>
    static Derived& get_instance()
    {
        static_assert(i < n, "Time to increase n it seems!");
        return instances[i];
    }
};

下面是如何使用它:

class SingletonExample : public n_ton_base<SingletonExample>
{
public:
    void method()
    {
        std::cout << "Singletons are overused.\n";
    }    
};

class DoubletonExample : public n_ton_base<DoubletonExample, 2>
{
public:
    void method()
    {
        std::cout << "Doubleton " << this << " says hello.\n";
    }    
};

int main()
{
    SingletonExample::get_instance().method();
    DoubletonExample::get_instance().method();
    DoubletonExample::get_instance<0>().method();
    DoubletonExample::get_instance<1>().method();
}

不幸的是，代码还没有编译:

/tmp/ccsFtliS.o: In function `SingletonExample& n_ton_base<SingletonExample, 1ul>::get_instance<0ul>()':
nton.cpp:(.text._ZN10n_ton_baseI16SingletonExampleLm1EE12get_instanceILm0EEERS0_v[SingletonExample& n_ton_base<SingletonExample, 1ul>::get_instance<0ul>()]+0x5): undefined reference to `n_ton_base<SingletonExample, 1ul>::instances'
/tmp/ccsFtliS.o: In function `DoubletonExample& n_ton_base<DoubletonExample, 2ul>::get_instance<0ul>()':
nton.cpp:(.text._ZN10n_ton_baseI16DoubletonExampleLm2EE12get_instanceILm0EEERS0_v[DoubletonExample& n_ton_base<DoubletonExample, 2ul>::get_instance<0ul>()]+0x5): undefined reference to `n_ton_base<DoubletonExample, 2ul>::instances'
/tmp/ccsFtliS.o: In function `DoubletonExample& n_ton_base<DoubletonExample, 2ul>::get_instance<1ul>()':
nton.cpp:(.text._ZN10n_ton_baseI16DoubletonExampleLm2EE12get_instanceILm1EEERS0_v[DoubletonExample& n_ton_base<DoubletonExample, 2ul>::get_instance<1ul>()]+0x5): undefined reference to `n_ton_base<DoubletonExample, 2ul>::instances'
collect2: ld gab 1 als Ende-Status zurück

我做错了什么？

Answer 1

作为Etienne Cordonnier pointed out ，使用局部静态而不是类静态要容易得多:

template<typename Derived, size_t n = 1>
class n_ton_base                 // Singletons are the default
{
protected:

    // Prevent n_ton_base to be used outside of inheritance hierarchies
    n_ton_base() {} 

    // Prevent n_ton_base (and Derived classes) from being copied
    n_ton_base(const n_ton_base&) = delete;

public:
                   // Get first element by default, useful for Singletons
    template<size_t i = 0>
    static Derived& get_instance()
    {
        static_assert(i < n, "Time to increase n it seems!");

        static Derived instance;
        return instance;
    }
};

请注意，每个实例化的成员函数都有自己的局部静态，因此不需要数组。

这也实现了thread-safe lazy initialization无需我做任何事情。不错!