c++ - 为什么 if constexpr 需要 else 才能工作？

Question

我正在尝试按以下方式使用 if constexpr:

template<template <typename First, typename Second> class Trait,
    typename First, typename Second, typename... Rest>
constexpr bool binaryTraitAre_impl()
{
    if constexpr (sizeof... (Rest) == 0)
    {
        return Trait<First, Second>{}();    
    }
    return Trait<First, Second>{}() and binaryTraitAre_impl<Trait, Rest...>();
}

示例用例:

static_assert(binaryTraitAre_impl<std::is_convertible,
    int, int&,
    int*, void*>());

但是编译失败

clang :

error: no matching function for call to 'binaryTraitAre_impl'
        return Trait<First, Second>{}() and binaryTraitAre_impl<Trait, Rest...>();
                                            ^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

gcc :

prog.cc: In instantiation of 'constexpr bool binaryTraitAre_impl() [with Trait = std::is_convertible; First = int*; Second = void*; Rest = {}]':
prog.cc:9:80:   required from 'constexpr bool binaryTraitAre_impl() [with Trait = std::is_convertible; First = int; Second = int&; Rest = {int*, void*}]'
prog.cc:15:83:   required from here
prog.cc:9:80: error: no matching function for call to 'binaryTraitAre_impl<template<class _From, class _To> struct std::is_convertible>()'
    9 |         return Trait<First, Second>{}() and binaryTraitAre_impl<Trait, Rest...>();
      |                                             ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~
prog.cc:3:17: note: candidate: 'template<template<class First, class Second> class Trait, class First, class Second, class ... Rest> constexpr bool binaryTraitAre_impl()'
    3 |  constexpr bool binaryTraitAre_impl()
      |                 ^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
prog.cc:3:17: note:   template argument deduction/substitution failed:
prog.cc:9:80: note:   couldn't deduce template parameter 'First'
    9 |         return Trait<First, Second>{}() and binaryTraitAre_impl<Trait, Rest...>();
      |                                             ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^~

但我发现添加 else 后错误消失了:

template<template <typename First, typename Second> class Trait,
    typename First, typename Second, typename... Rest>
constexpr bool binaryTraitAre_impl()
{
    if constexpr (sizeof... (Rest) == 0)
    {
        return Trait<First, Second>{}();
    }
    else
    {
        return Trait<First, Second>{}() and binaryTraitAre_impl<Trait, Rest...>();
    }
}

live demo

发生了什么事？为什么在这种情况下编译器不能推断出 else？

Answer 1

这是 constexpr if 上的 cppreference 的摘录:

Constexpr If The statement that begins with if constexpr is known as the constexpr if statement.

In a constexpr if statement, the value of condition must be a contextually converted constant expression of type bool. If the value is true, then statement-false is discarded (if present), otherwise, statement-true is discarded.

很明显，两个分支中只有一个被丢弃了。在您的情况下，不能丢弃罪魁祸首代码，因为它在 else 子句之外。